Skip to content
Cloud Chasers Get the briefing

How should employers handle disability claims and accommodation requests under the ADAAA?

It Just Rewrote the Definition of “Disability”

I think what people have the most trouble with about the Americans with Disabilities Act Amendments Act is the idea that it was some sort of total overhaul of the Americans with Disabilities Act. All of the other stuff in the ADA – the anti-discrimination provisions, reasonable accommodation requirements, confidentiality obligations, medical exam regulations, etc. – were untouched by the ADAAA. So my best advice is, make sure that you treat people fairly and do reasonable accommodation the right way, and you won’t get in trouble with the ADA. You just can’t argue that someone ”isn’t disabled” anymore.

Tips to Help You Avoid ADA Trouble

To help with all that, here are some of my favorite tips to help you avoid ADA trouble (i.e., plaintiffs’ lawyers):

Don’t get into arguments over whether your employee is “disabled.” As I’ve just said, the definition of “disability” is so broad these days that it’s a waste of time to debate whether this is going on unless you are talking about a cold or the flu. Instead, just assume your employee has a “disability,” and that puts your attention where it needs to be, which is making a fair decision, and a decision that you can justify if anyone asks you to.

Don’t let medical conditions enter into your employment decisions unless it would prevent the person from doing the job effectively, or there is a threat to health or safety whether or not reasonable accommodations are provided. (But don’t forget – even if there is a threat, you have to make the reasonable accommodation if you can.) OK, this is obvious, but I thought it was worth saying.

Unless the disability is obvious or no one would dispute it, verify it with medical documentation from a qualified medical professional. (Don’t forget that the ADAAA didn’t eliminate your right to do this!)

Talk it over with your employee – in other words, engage in the ”interactive process” for reasonable accommodation. In some jurisdictions, this is a legal requirement, but even if it’s not, it’s smart. Why? Because the employee may think of a quick and inexpensive way to accommodate her condition, or the employee may acknowledge that nothing would work. (The EEOC, which is otherwise kind of a meanie, actually recognizes that sometimes the employee’s suggestion of an accommodation is a lot simpler and more cost-effective than anything the employer had been considering.)

Do this stuff in the order recommended by the EEOC:

  • First, you try to accommodate the disability in the employee’s current job.
  • If that’s not possible, then you see if the disability can be accommodated in a similar position. (The more similar the duties, hours, pay, and benefits, the better – but a demotion, or a switch from full-time to part-time, may be fine.)
  • If that’s not possible, then you see if the employee’s disability can be accommodated in some other position.
  • If all else fails, medical leave, including FMLA leave if that is appropriate.
  • And your last resort – termination – should be reserved for cases when all of the above have failed.

Know what you don’t have to do. You don’t have to create a job that doesn’t exist, bump another employee, promote, or eliminate the essential functions of the job. The ADA doesn’t require you to buy an employee personal items like wheelchairs, eyeglasses, or hearing aids. On the other hand, doing these things may in some cases be an easier or cheaper fix than trying to accommodate in some other way, so don’t rule out possibilities just because they’re not required.

Light Duty

Don’t confuse “light duty” with “reasonable accommodation.” Employers and employees mix these two things up all the time. ”Light duty” is something that is usually set up for an employee to help him recover from a work injury covered by workers’ comp. It’s often “make-work,” and it’s usually temporary. You can set conditions for light duty or restrictions on light duty, or you don’t have to offer light duty at all. A ”reasonable accommodation” is something required by the ADA, to be offered by covered employers. An accommodation is an alteration to an actual job, not a separate temporary job. There is no limit on how long a reasonable accommodation may continue. Instead, the reasonable accommodation has to change as the conditions of the employee’s disability change, so that it remains an accommodation. In that way, a duty to provide reasonable accommodation could literally last for the duration of the employment.

Cloud Chasers Editors