Not that long ago a legal matter meant a call to the local lawyer, who handled just about everything for the business.
As the legal profession’s clients grow more cost-conscious, they are sending requests for proposal (RFPs) to several law firms, not just one, letting firms bid against each other on whatever matters are at stake.
The pile of RFPs keeps growing. It may rest on an attorney’s desk for weeks before getting to marketing. There follows a hectic scramble to meet the deadline. Throughout it all, firms stay hopeful that they’ll win the business, whether it’s a long-running litigation or a short-term project.
When firms do respond, it’s an opportunity to stand out from the crowd. Still, sometimes an RFP wastes so much time, talent and money that ignoring it altogether is the smartest choice.
Peter Darling looked at it another way. Sure, the whole process was supposedly objective, impartial. Yet he found that legal work is personal, driven by relationships. For that reason, the likely winner had often been picked beforehand, he said. The RFP allowed the client to say it looked at 15 law firms.
Darling, who spoke Oct. 8 at a Legal Marketing Association Rocky Mountain Chapter monthly education event at Sullivan’s Steakhouse in LoDo, Denver, started his company, Repechage Group, in Santa Cruz, Calif. He is a lawyer with experience in marketing and advertising, as well as graphic design.
Politely Decline About 40 Percent of RFPs
Answering every RFP that comes in is tempting, but it’s impractical, too. Every proposal costs a lot of money and takes a lot of time. Many proposals have no real chance of winning.
Darling’s rule: Respond only when there’s at least a 50/50 chance of winning, and politely decline about 40 percent of RFPs. Draft a concrete set of criteria for taking on, or passing up, an RFP. Create a committee with the authority to put each proposal either in the file cabinet or the trash bin.
Client Focused
A proposal can’t be haphazardly thrown together, Darling said. It must be client focused and provide convincing reasons why your firm should win.
Attorneys are taught to write clear, concise, airtight contracts and other legal papers. All that’s fine. It’s another matter to keep a proposal from reading like a trial court pleading. Yet a proposal often struggles to win because it reads like a bland legal document and lacks personality.
In law, facts speak for themselves. Proposals must present strong facts, but the facts must be interpreted and framed. Just presenting a stack of facts or legal authority does little to persuade.
A proposal is essentially a sales document. Lawyers can read a boring brief. A prospect can ignore a boring proposal. Boring proposals go unread and lost under a pile of work and mail.
Strong proposals look and sound distinct. They take a point of view and stick to it. Above all, the proposal is about the client’s problems.
Lawyers love to talk about themselves, and it’s not hard to see why. It’s tempting to load the proposal with information about the firm’s honors and histories. Still, many proposals grow stuffed with boilerplate and biographies. At times, proposals cram in so many biographies that about 60 percent of the content involves the individual lawyers.
It’s better to focus on client problems, and then the firm’s solutions. It’s tough to put yourself aside, but those egotistical opening pages must go. It’s best to avoid even naming the firm in the first three pages.
Whatever you say about your firm must tie back into how it will help the client solve his problems. Firm information is only supporting evidence, not a page-long parade of achievements, national awards and honors. Explain how your firm helps clients save money, make money or keep their customers happy, Darling said. Out of that context, awards and citations are only decoration.
Client-centric means the proposal reflects the client’s business strategy, that is, how the client competes and sets itself apart from its competitors. It shows an appreciation of the market dynamics that drive their strategic thinking.
While the research takes time and expertise, it’s worth the effort. The firm might look at the client’s website, social media, annual reports, and news articles and Google searches, all to gather information about the client’s strategy.
In the proposal, state right away what the client’s strategy seems to be. Be direct: No pussyfooting about strategy is allowed. Identify the strategy, then explain how your firm can help the client achieve its strategic objectives. Don’t be shy about stepping up to say, “Your strategy is x and we’re going to help you do y.”
For instance, if the client’s strategy is diversity, point out the firm’s women and minority lawyers. If innovation, show the technology the firm uses to improve service and cut costs. If green, stress that the firm supports the environment.
Mirroring the client’s strategy is good because it reveals that a firm has actually done its homework and cares about the client. It shows interest in the client’s wider business. Many clients also consider it important that firms share their business philosophy.
Design Is a Proposal’s Suit
A winning proposal grabs a reader’s eye with a creative design, like a glossy annual report, or snazzy magazine. Design is a proposal’s suit. Or the way an attorney dresses well to meet a client. Good design sets the proposal apart from the rest and shows that the firm cares enough about the client to send a well produced proposal, not something cheaply slapped together.
While attorneys may want to believe that winning is rational, that the firm whose legal work is most excellent wins, choice is mostly emotional. Design makes the initial impression and can make a lasting impression. The aim should be for designs that are professional, modern, clean and well organized.
A firm might want to use the client’s own visual style. For instance, the firm might echo the flow charts, visual style, choice of photos and infographics. Use photos of firm attorneys to illustrate key points, instead of stock images. A picture may say 1,000 words, and stock photography has no words at all. People in stock images have no identity.
Avoid the jargon of legalese, even when the readers are general counsel. Be organized, conversational, relaxed. Be an expert talking to non-experts. Don’t fear simply telling a story. That is, begin with a problem or issue, then describe how you helped the client solve it. It helps to have a non-lawyer read the proposal with an eye to clarity.
Imagine that it’s a rainy afternoon at 3:30. A pile of proposals fills a general counsel’s desk, and the client is just starting to go through them. It’s heavy going. The proposals look alike; most read the same way.
A client will remember little about each firm he talks to. Darling says most clients can remember only three things per firm, no more. Make sure those three things set you apart and matter.
Those are the so-called win themes. The firm must stay on them, the way a politician stays on message or an advertiser uses a tagline. That’s what controls what the client remembers about you.
Keep win themes short, simple and to the point. Repeat them in sections of text, in graphics. Repeat win themes often enough to help get the key points across, but without turning off the reader. Use win themes to organize sections, in headlines, subheads, breakout quotes and shaded backgrounds.
All this takes tremendous work, sweat and heart. But a persuasive proposal that stands out from the rest is what you must have. Otherwise, the client will never read it, never remember it.
Even a losing proposal may pay off. Many prospects keep proposals around in case they need them later. They may not hire you now, but a losing proposal ends up in their files for future needs. The long shelf life means all the more reason to give proposals the time and polish needed for a lasting impression.