Skip to content
Cloud Chasers Get the briefing

Should I choose a merchant cash advance or a business loan?

Many small businesses and startups need extra money at some point, whether it is for growth, to cover overhead, for refinancing, or to chase a promising opportunity.

Friends and family can get you only so far. When you have nothing left to offer, where do you go? You go to alternative financing.

Alternative lenders tend to give you a single lump sum of cash, which is often what a small shop or owner needs to launch the business toward success.

Getting a small business loan is often overwhelming, because there is just so much to choose from in the industry. Both traditional and alternative business loans have their own sets of requirements and downsides. Be mindful of those and choose a lender and terms that work best with your business and the industry you are in.

Knowing the Structural Differences

Merchant cash advances and small business loans have the same goal: to give you cash right away. The fine print is why one type may be better than the other for your company, and knowing the structural differences helps you make a smart decision.

The difference between getting a loan and a cash advance from a merchant funding company has a lot to do with the initial application and the terms. A loan tends to have more requirements. One appeals to those with spotty credit and the other requires at least decent credit, but both solutions come with trade-offs. With a cash advance, no matter how much you sell over a day, a percentage is set aside for the MCAs repayment, whereas a business loan has set repayment terms and interests.

An MCA has a quicker application and needs less information. You pay a fixed percentage of your revenue. The payments thus ebb and flow with how well the business sells. It is approved more often than a loan.

With a term loan, you get a set amount with set monthly payments. Small banks and the SBA are the main lenders. The rates are in the 7.5% to 10% range. You can add extra to the payment when you have more cash, and that in turn cuts the overall interest.

Banks are usually the first stop after borrowing from family and friends. Owners borrow $600 billion every year, according to the SBA, mostly to expand.

Loan applications are tougher. Personal service shops get approved just 16% of the time, while hospitality and restaurant fares much better (51%), according to Forbes. Other industries tend to fall somewhere between those.

Most banks look for credit scores of at least 700. Low-end scores need stronger business credentials to convince a bank to take a chance. Most loans require at least a year operating, and you can get a business loan with as little as $50,000 yearly revenue.

To banks, you are more than a business. If your personal debt is high and credit is low, they may say no. Many lenders like at least a 1.25 net operating income to expenses ratio. Banks also may require collateral (usually equipment, inventory or real estate) and set limits on what the money can be used for.

MCA Requirements Are Not as Restrictive

Most MCAs offer daily or weekly repayment, and the amount is based on your sales for the day. The Federal Reserve did a survey and found that 79% of those who applied were approved. To qualify, you need at least a 500 credit score, been open at least three months, and can have no more than five overdrafts or NSFs.

MCAs let you do what you will with the advance, whereas with a small business loan, you have to use it for certain things. MCAs are typically repaid in less than 2 years, often 18 months, whereas small business loans extend up to 5 years.

One thing to remember is SBA loans are more often turned down than approved. Even so, business loans can hit a couple million, whereas merchant cash advances max out at $500,000.

An MCA is the quickest solution and easiest to qualify for. It is usually also the most convenient for a lot of businesses because repayment follows sales and the fund amount may be used as you see fit. There is no collateral and no lengthy application. The initial application and the approval and funding process is typically completed within a couple days.

The Final Decision

In the end, MCAs are better in that they are easy to get and give access to cash in a hurry. MCAs are still an expensive way to borrow money, though, and it is not regulated at this time, so you should consider your customer base and industry when deciding if it would be a good solution or not. You must also use a credit card processor. Loans require a lot of paperwork and info, plus collateral and very good credit. They work differently and may appeal to different kinds of businesses. The final decision comes down to access and what you can afford to repay.

Cloud Chasers Editors