Every business faces tough times every now and then. Unexpected problems crop up. Rough cash flow weeks (or months) happen. Having a line of credit at the bank helps. When the cash flow keeps getting worse, though, each new lender is more expensive and more restrictive than the last.
Lenders of Last Resort
Merchant cash advance lenders are called lenders of last resort. Deservedly. Approval within 24 to 48 hours is a big plus for stressed business owners. Not needing collateral is usually a plus, too, until they discover they’re still liable personally for any deficiencies. Payment is made by repaying a percentage of future sales, so when times get even tougher and sales decrease, so does the repayment, which sounds attractive. What’s not attractive is the contract. Full of legalese and obscure language, these documents contain many surprises, some of them quite unpleasant.
Merchant cash advance companies aren’t regulated as lenders, so they operate under state Uniform Commercial Code rules – no usury limits, no limit on stacking advances.
Merchant cash advance fees aren’t calculated as interest so the companies don’t show rates at all. With normal loans the effective rate depends on the amount and timing of payments, but with an MCA you repay a fixed multiple of the amount borrowed. Fees vary, but a real rate of anywhere from the low 30s to over 200% a year is not uncommon.
In the contract the MCA states there’s no prepayment penalty, meaning the fee stays the same whether you pay early or late. Technically it’s true, but that doesn’t tell the whole story. The cost – the full fee – is due whenever the loan is repaid. Paying early actually raises the effective rate.
By tying repayment to sales, a merchant cash advance lender moves its payment ahead of the bank’s. If the MCA company already has direct access to the business’s operating account, it’s easy to take its share before the business owner gets any money. Bankers don’t like this much. The business and its traditional lenders are at risk. The business is suddenly facing an existential threat, and its ABL lender faces a sudden threat to its secured position. If it gets cut off from its operating funds, it can’t restock inventory or pay bills on time.
MCA contracts also usually include a confession of judgment. By signing it, the borrower gives up its right to defend itself in court.
For a struggling company, debt can become something of an addiction. Treating cash flow issues with debt is no substitute for reinventing the company.
Perhaps the biggest problem is repaying one of these loans. When revenue declines, the borrower can’t repay it and has to get another advance to refinance. Taking a new, even costlier advance is just digging a deeper hole, and virtually guarantees insolvency.
UCC Article 9
A better option, one many owners are only now discovering, is the stream-lined, out-of-court business reorganization found in UCC Article 9. It is a private short sale of the business’s assets. The business continues to operate during and after. All subordinate debt is wiped out. Most sales of this kind are done in 30-60 days at modest cost.
What’s so good about an Article 9 sale? The lender often recovers more than in a bankruptcy. Everybody wins.
How it works: Article 9 allows the senior secured creditor – the lender – to sell the operating business’s assets to a buyer who will keep running them. By statute the Article 9 sale, in effect, clears the sold assets of all liens and liabilities.
Current operations, jobs and enterprise value all carry over into the new entity under the new owners. But the corporate entity stays behind, and with it goes all of the subordinate debt.
Too many owners think of themselves as being shut out of any chance to go on. But the right buyer may let the seller stay on, either under an employment agreement or as a minority partner. Some see this as a way to satisfy personal guaranties with the senior lender, so everyone makes out. It is a clean start and new life for an existing company.
A business reorganization sale needs two things to work.
First, a realistic restructuring plan that fixes the core problems and is likely to bring eventual profitability. It’s better to bring in an experienced outside turnaround expert than to depend on the current management. Not acting early can let even stronger companies slip into bankruptcy, where all choices are out of their hands. Doing the right things early can bring results.
Second, the right team. Use one that specializes in Article 9 sales and has a strong track record. Compared to bankruptcy attorneys, specialists in this method have less overhead so they charge less.